McGarrah's Stagecoach Inn

McGarrah's Inn is a Federal-style stagecoach inn and tavern on Stage Road in Monroe, built in the late 1700s (sources give dates from about 1790 to 1799). Freemasons met here from 1817 to 1826, and its 1817 Lodge Room is billed as the oldest Masonic meeting room in New York State. Cornerstone Lodge No. 711 bought the building in 1998, the year it was listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and the nonprofit Cornerstone Masonic Historical Society now works to preserve it.

The historic marker notes that some claim the building is haunted and that it has appeared on several paranormal TV shows, including a two-part investigation on Playing with Fire. One paranormal group that visited said it could not confirm the claim that the inn is among the Hudson Valley's most haunted places, but reported that its wireless camera screen turned red in the basement with no explanation.