Hannah House

Alexander Hannah, a respected Indiana state legislator and abolitionist, built this 24-room house in 1858. Local legend holds it was a station on the Underground Railroad, and that a group of freedom seekers sheltering in the basement died when a knocked-over oil lamp set the space ablaze — but Indianapolis historians have found no actual evidence the house was ever part of the Underground Railroad network, and consider the fire story local myth rather than documented history. What is real: Hannah's own family history in the house, including the birth of a stillborn child to a Hannah descendant, and decades of consistent reports from owners, staff, and visitors — cold drafts, doors opening and closing on their own, disembodied voices, and an overwhelming smell in one upstairs room some liken to decay.