Windham Inn

Local legend ties this 1783 inn — originally three stories, reduced to two after it began to buckle around 1850, and converted to apartments in the 20th century — to the ghost of Elizabeth "Betsy" Shaw. In 1744, unmarried and pregnant, Betsy was shunned by her neighbors and reported to authorities by her own father; her newborn was found dead, and she was convicted and hanged by an all-male jury. The timeline doesn't actually line up — Betsy died decades before this inn was built — but local storytelling has long placed her ghost here anyway, walking the nearby road and the inn's hallways, where residents report hearing a baby crying with no infant in the building.